Last fall an Ohio woman blamed Besvis and Butt-head
for her 5-year-old son's setting fire to their trailer
home, killing her 2-year-old daughter. Neighbors say
the family did not get cable, yet Beavis and Butt-head
was widely reviled as evidence of TV's corrupting influence
on the young and its supposed role in promoting violence.
In February a New York-based watchdog group, Morality
in Media, said Beavis and Butt-head might be responsible
for the death of an 8-year-old girl, killed when a bowling
ball was thrown from an overpass onto a New Jersey highway
and struck her famity's car. The group cited an episode
of the show in which Beavis and Butt-head loaded a bowling
ball with explosives and dropped it from a rooftop. "We're
not saying there is a connection", said Betty Wein, a
Morality in Media spokesperson, saying there was a connection.
"But certainly the coincidence is difficult to ignore."
Newspapers report this "coincidence" prominently, and CNN
and local TV stations ran clips from Beavis and Butt-head
next to photos of the child before she died. As it turned
out, the 18-year-old arrested for throwing the bowling ball
didn't get cable, either. It was only when the local prosecutor
announsed there was no evidence of a connection between the
killing and the programm that the media withdrew.
"It saddens and amazes me," sais the show's creator,Mike Judge.
"To link the program to a tragedy like that with absolutely
no evidence - it's just ubelievable."
"It gets into your head," Judge sais. "You get an idea that
you think will be funny, and then you think, 'But look at how
they'll react to it.' I've gotten so tired that I don't feel
like fighting big battles."
The voices in Judge's head are precisely what civil libertarians
call the "chilling effect" - fears and pressures that dull or
still a creative or reportorial voice. MTV and its parent
corporatio, Viacom, have contributed to this. After the Ohio
controversy, the network moved the show to a later time slot
and muted it's content. "Some of MTV and Viacom's top people
are scared to death," says a producer connected to the program.
"People have no idea how many episodes have been altered by
network executives, toned down. And the creepy thing is that
lots of the attacks come from the press, the people who are
always yelling about freedom." Even the liberal weekly The Nation,
in an editorial agaist government censorship, called the show
"repulsive" and essentially blamed it for the death of the
child in Ohio.
Judge says he can't figure out what makes adults - especially
those who can remember their own parents panicking about Elvis
or long hair - so hostile to his program. For many baby-boom
parents, it seems, Beavis and Butt-head is not just another
dumb show they can't stand but a symbol of all the dumb stuff
they can't stand that pours into the house through these wretched
TV and computer screens.
The most striking thing about the furor over the program,
however, is that it's supposed to be funny. It gives kids an
opportunity to laugh at themselves and us. Grown-ups don't
get that this programis unique and valuable precisely because
it brilliantly lampoonns the qualities it is accused of
propaganding - stupidity, sexism, the simple-minded, macho-rites
of adolescence.
Accusations like those against Beavis and Butt-head make
life easier for politicians and journalists who don't know or
want to know how to tackle the real issues that affect
children in America. The program is currently unavailable to
younger children, driven off its earlier time slot to protect
them from its bad influence. Guns, drugs, overcrowded schools
and homes without parents are still plentiful and accessible.
|